Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At the Strickler Agency, we are proud to have so many experienced team members. No matter your insurance needs, we’ll have the right person ready to assist you, your family or your business.
Commercial Sales & Service
Pat Abbott

Pat Abbott
Commercial Risk Advisor

Eric Altenburger

Eric Altenburger
Vice President Operations

Jackie Antes

Jackie Antes
Commercial Lines Operations Manager

Erin Brownawell

Erin Brownawell
Select Business Unit Operations Manager

Jason Crider

Jason Crider
Commercial Risk Advisor

Penni DeHart

Penni DeHart
Assistant Business Insurance Specialist

Tina Garman

Tina Garman
Account Executive

Traci Halter

Traci Halter
Assistant Business Insurance Specialist

Darleen Martelli

Darleen Martelli
Client Service Specialist

Steve McElhiney

Steve McElhiney
Business Insurance Specialist

Amy Miller

Amy Miller
Account Executive

Sarah Miller

Sarah Miller
Business Insurance Specialist

Erik Olsen

Erik Olsen
President, CEO

Sara Rhine

Sara Rhine
Commercial Risk Advisor

Roxi Seilhamer

Roxi Seilhamer
Commercial Risk Advisor, Human Resources Manager

Jackie Shank

Jackie Shank
Claims Representative

Reed VanDerlyke

Reed VanDerlyke
Director of Sales

Jason W. Smith

Jason W. Smith
Risk Manager

Michelle Yeager

Michelle Yeager
Business Insurance Specialist

Jade Young

Jade Young
Business Insurance Specialist

Agri-Business Sales & Service
Mark Goodhart

Mark Goodhart
Vice President Agriculture

Martina Horst

Martina Horst
Assistant Business Insurance Specialist

Deelana Kennedy

Deelana Kennedy
Business Insurance Specialist

Laura Miller

Laura Miller
Business Insurance Specialist

Personal Sales & Service
Lori Baker

Lori Baker
Personal Lines Operations Manager

Christine Burkholder

Christine Burkholder
Personal Insurance Specialist

Miranda Lake

Miranda Lake
Personal Insurance Specialist

Lindsay Metcalf

Lindsay Metcalf
Personal Insurance Specialist

Kristin Speece

Kristin Speece
Private Client Relationship Manager

Katie Wilson

Katie Wilson
Personal Insurance Specialist

Employee Benefits Sales & Service
Susana Duff

Susana Duff
Employee Benefits Account Associate

Keith Goddard

Keith Goddard
Employee Benefits Operations Supervisor

Stephanie Hoover

Stephanie Hoover
Employee Benefits Lead Account Associate

Sara Schweitz

Sara Schweitz
Employee Benefits Consultant

Tom Shearer

Tom Shearer
Employee Benefits Consultant

Tanya Wehr

Tanya Wehr
Employee Benefits Account Associate

Operations
Kevin J. Duffy III

Kevin J. Duffy III
Agent in Training

Jennifer Ingram

Jennifer Ingram
Bookkeeper

Lee Ann Pentek

Lee Ann Pentek
IT/Accounting Assistant

Roxi Seilhamer

Roxi Seilhamer
Commercial Risk Advisor, Human Resources Manager

Jackie Shank

Jackie Shank
Claims Representative

Karla Suders

Karla Suders
Receptionist

Mindy VanDerlyke

Mindy VanDerlyke
Director of Business Development and Communications