Erin Schutter

Erin Schutter

Employee Benefits Consultant


Erin began her insurance career as a college intern with a local insurance agency while attending Shippensburg University. Through that experience, she gained a comprehensive understanding of agency operations and what clients value most. She specializes in developing strategic employee benefits solutions for employers of all sizes and funding arrangements, helping organizations strengthen their bottom line while enhancing the employee experience. Erin works closely with clients to analyze claims data, identify opportunities for cost savings, support contract and union negotiations, and educate employees on their benefits. Drawing from both her professional expertise and personal experiences navigating the healthcare system with her daughter and family members, she is passionate about helping clients and their employees make informed healthcare decisions.

Erin lives in New Cumberland with her husband, daughter, and two dogs. She is committed to giving back to the community through her volunteer work with the Community Aid Foundation and other local organizations. Outside of work, Erin enjoys cheering on her daughter at field hockey games, hiking, practicing yoga, spending time with family and friends, and supporting her favorite Syracuse and Philadelphia sports teams.